Doubles Calls?
Q. In doubles, if a player calls a serve “out” and his partner overrules him and says “no, that was in” is the point to be played over or does it become the server’s point since the original call was incorrect? I say it is the server’s point whether in a sanctioned tournament or in friendly play. My friend says you only follow that rule in big time competition. When should one distinguish when the “correct” rules apply?
A. Technically, you are right. A rule is a rule. However, in friendly competition, it is normal- and widely accepted- that a let can be played under the circumstances that you described. Remember, you are three friends having fun and trying to be fair. If the call that you described was an ace (or an unreturnable serve), then you should definitely award your opponent(s) the point though.